American Pie Council

2009 National Pie Champions

Junior Chef Winners

Place Entrant Pie Flavor City, State
  Carmela Crutcher Tropical Italian Pie Best of Show Orlando, FL
1 Alex Rameriz Most Creative - Cherries Down Under Pie Crisco® Classic Cherry Polk City, FL
1 Christiana Hurt Most Flavorful - Banana Cream Pie Banana Longwood, FL
1 Carmela Crutcher Best Appearance - Tropical Italian Pie Tropical Orlando, FL

Amateur Winners

Place Entrant Pie Flavor City, State
  Phyllis Szymanek Category Five Peanut Butter Pie Best of Show Toledo, OH
1 Lana Ross Harvest Apple Pie Apple Indianola, IA
2 Carolyn Blakemore Golden Apple Pie Apple Fairmont, WV
3 Bev Johnson Butterscotch Pecan Apple Pie Apple Crookston, MN
1 Patricia Lapiezo Rocky S'Mores Pie Crisco® Classic Chocolate LaMesa, CA
2 Jeanne Ely Shades of Chocolate Crisco® Classic Chocolate Mulberry, FL
3 Carol Socier Mound Mountain Chocolate Cream Pie Crisco® Classic Chocolate Bay City, MI
1 Nikki Norman Classic Cherry Studel-Topped Pie Crisco® Classic Cherry Milton, TN
2 Evette Rahman Black Cherry Pie Crisco® Classic Cherry Orlando, FL
3 Carolyn Blakemore Classy Cherry Pie Crisco® Classic Cherry Fairmont, WV
1 John Sunvold Afternoon Delight Pie Citrus Winter Springs, FL
2 Christine Fiedorwicz Mango-licious Key Lime Pie Citrus Denver, CO
3 Phyllis Szymanek Kumquat Tropical Delight Pie Citrus Toledo, OH
1 Christine Montalvo Tres Leches Cream Pie Cream Windsor Heights, IA
2 Carol Socier Island Breeze Pinapple Blueberry Cream Pie Cream Bay City, MI
3 Barbara J. Polk Butterscotch Cream Albuquerque, NM
1 Patricia Lapiezo Meyer Lemon Cheese Pie Cream Cheese LaMesa, CA
2 Amy Mills Clemons Dark Chocolate Raspberry Truffle Pie Cream Cheese Babson Park, FL
3 Jennifer Nystrom Chocolate Hazelnut Dream Pie Cream Cheese Morrow, OH
1 Carol Socier Butterscotch Pecan Custard Pie Custard Bay City, MI
2 Rick Johnson Caramel Roll Pie Custard Belleville, IL
3 Christine Fiedorowicz Vanilla Custard with Lemonberry Blaze Custard Denver, CO
1 John Sunvold Ginger, You're a Peach Pie Fruit & Berry Winter Springs, FL
2 Evette Rahman Summertime Peach Blueberry Pie Fruit & Berry Orlando, FL
3 Diane Finney Here we go gathering Nuts and Berries Pie Fruit & Berry Celebration, FL
1 Christine Montalvo Vermont Maple Pecan Pie Nut Windsor Heights, IA
1 Dianne C. Reeves Cajun Pecan Pie Nut Jennings, LA
3 Evette Rahman A Date with a Nut Pie Nut Orlando, FL
1 John Sunvold Iron Chef Lime Pie Open Winter Springs, FL
2 Beth Campbell Chocolate Raspberry Cordial Pie Open Belleville, WI
3 Linda Schiessl Peaches & Creamy Cranberry Pie Open Ford du Lac, WI
1 Jill Jones Real Pumpkin Pie Pumpkin Palm Bay, FL
2 Alberta Dunbar Pumpkin Surprise w/Crystallized Ginger Sour Cream Topping Pumpkin San Diego, CA
3 Beth Campbell Honey of a Cream Cheese Pumpkin Patch Pie Pumpkin Belleville, WI
1 Patricia Lapiezo Maple Oatmeal Raisin Pie Raisin LaMesa, CA
2 Carol Socier Golden Nugget Raisin Pie Raisin Bay City, MI
3 Janet Ropp Sunshine Raisin Pie Raisin Edgewater, FL
1 Laura Francese Splenda-did Peanut Butter Pie Splenda® Gerry, NY
2 Patti Sharrard Splenda Caramel Apple Pie Splenda® Ruby, MI
3 Terry Beaver Stawberry Smoothie Pie Splenda® Olalla, WA
1 Carolyn Blakemore Sweet Potato w/Pecan Topping Pie Sweet Potato Fairmont, WV
2 Christine Montalvo Sweet Potato Praline Pie Sweet Potato Windsor Heights, IA
3 Nikki Norman Southern-Style Sweet Potato Pie Sweet Potato Milton, TN
1 Phyllis Szymanek Category Five Peanut Butter Pie Peanut Butter Toledo, OH
2 Patricia Lapiezo Peanut Butter Explosion Pie Peanut Butter LaMesa, CA
3 Jeanne Ely Lip Smokin' No Bakem' Peanut Butter Pie Peanut Butter Mulberry, FL

Professional Winners

Place Entrant Pie Flavor City, State
  Linda Hundt Tom's Cheery Cherry Cherry Berry Pie Best of Show DeWitt, MI
1 Dawn M. Viola Vanilla-Vanilla Bean Roasted Apple Pie Apple Orlando, FL
2 Pamela Williams Gooey Apple Crunch Pie Apple Thornton, CO
1 Diane Selich Chocolate Truffle Surprise Pie Crisco® Classic Chocolate Vassar, MI
2 Dionna Hurt Chocolate Créme Brulee Crisco® Classic Chocolate Longwood, FL
1 Linda Hundt Tom's Cheery Cherry Cherry Berry Pie Crisco® Classic Cherry DeWitt, MI
2 Valarie Enters Classic Cherry Revised Crisco® Classic Cherry Altamonte Springs, FL
1 Matthew Zagorski Grandma Ellie's Lemon Birthday Pie Citrus Arlington Heights, IL
2 Andy Hilton Key Lime and Blackberry Pie Citrus Davenport, FL
1 Raine Gottess Campfire Fun Pie Cream Canton, OH
2 Katheryn Hanson S'mores Campfire Pie Cream Orlando, FL
1 Valarie Enters Sunday Dinner Strawberry Pie Fruit & Berry Altamonte Springs, FL
2 Matthew Zagorski Very Berry Mannelo Pie Fruit & Berry Arlington Heights, IL
1 Bryan Ehrenholm Sometimes You Feel Like a Nut Pie Nut Modesto, CO
2 Michele Albano Butterscotch Pecan Pie Nut Norwalk, CT
1 Susan Boyle Tropical Dream Coconut Cream Pie Open DeBary, FL
2 Bryan Ehrenholm Hula-licious Pie Open Modesto, CA

Commercial Winners

Entrant Category Pie Flavor
The Schwan Food Company 4" Single Pie Edwards Cherry Mini-Pie Fruit & Berry
Jessie Lord Bakery LLC 6" Single Pie 6" Apple Crumb Apple
Rocky Mountain Pies 6" Single Pie 6" VIP Cherry Pomegranate Lattice Fruit & Berry
Bonert's Slice of Pie 6" Single Pie Coconut Custard Open
Rocky Mountain Pies 6" Single Pie 6" Lemon Meringue Pastry Crust Open Cream
Publix Super Markets. Inc 6" Single Pie Publix Mixed Berry Pie New Product
Bonert's Slice of Pie Family Apple Apple
Publix Super Markets. Inc Family Publix Cherry Pie Crisco® Classic Cherry
Jessie Lord Bakery LLC Family Lemon Meringue 8" Shelf Stable Citrus
Cyrus O'Leary's Pies Family Old Fashioned Custard Pie Custard
Bonert's Slice of Pie Family Apple Berry Fruit & Berry
Boston Market Family Caramel Pecan Pie Nut
Bonert's Slice of Pie Family Stawberry Rhubarb Open
Bonert's Slice of Pie Family Pumpkin Pumpkin
J. Horner Family Snappy Raisin Supreme Raisin
Jessie Lord Bakery LLC Family Dutch Apple 8" Apple Crumb
Harlan Bakeries Family Banana Cream Banana Cream
Bonert's Slice of Pie Family Berry Berry
Jessie Lord Bakery LLC Family Blueberry 8" Blueberry
J. Horner Family Cookies and Cream Candy/Cookie Cream
J. Horner Family Chocolate Mint Chocolate Cream
Harlan Bakeries Family Coconut Cream Coconut Cream
J. Horner Family Key Lime Key Lime
J. Horner Family Candy Cane Open Cream
J. Horner Family Rocky Road Open Cream
Cyrus O'Leary's Pies Family Golden Peach Pie Peach
J. Horner Family Peanut Butter Peanut Butter
J. Horner Family French Silk Silk Cream
Bakers Square Family Raspberry Blackberry Yogurt w/Granola Crust New Product
Jessie Lord Bakery LLC Family No Sugar Added 8" NSA Apple Apple
Hill and Valley Family No Sugar Added NSA Cherry Pie Crisco® Classic Cherry
Jessie Lord Bakery LLC Family No Sugar Added 8" NSA Lemon Meringue Citrus
Hill and Valley Family No Sugar Added SF Key Lime Fruit & Berry
Hill and Valley Family No Sugar Added SF Pecan Pie Nut
Jessie Lord Bakery LLC Family No Sugar Added 8" NSA Pineapple Open
Jessie Lord Bakery LLC Family No Sugar Added 8" NSA Pumpkin Shelf Stable Pumpkin
Hill and Valley Family No Sugar Added NSA Blueberry Pie Blueberry
Hill and Valley Family No Sugar Added NSA Pumpkin Créme Open Cream
Hill and Valley Family No Sugar Added NSA Peach Pie Peach
Bakers Square Gourmet Fruitabulous Apple Apple
Cyrus O'Leary's Pies Gourmet Ultimate Cherry Cheese Pie Crisco® Classic Cherry
Bakers Square Gourmet Lemon Supreme Citrus
Kroger Gourmet Dulce de Leche Custard
Bakers Square Gourmet Hawaiian Strawberry Fruit & Berry
Target Gourmet Bourbon Pecan Nut
Bob Evans Gourmet Whole Apple Dumpling Pie Open
Bakers Square Gourmet Pumpkin Cream Pumpkin
Bakers Square Gourmet Chocolate Brownie Raisinet Raisin
The Schwan Food Company Gourmet Mrs. Smith's Cinnamon Apple Crumb Apple Crumb
Bakers Square Gourmet Fresh Banana Brownie Bottom Banana Cream
Bakers Square Gourmet Wild Blueberry Pear Blueberry
Bakers Square Gourmet Mint Brownie Blast Candy/Cookie Cream
Bakers Square Gourmet European Chocolate Truffle Chocolate Cream
Bakers Square Gourmet Chocolate Coconut Almond Joy Coconut Cream
The Schwan Food Company Gourmet Edwards Key Lime Key Lime
Bakers Square Gourmet White Chocolate Cherry Dream Open Cream
Bakers Square Gourmet Caramel Pecan Silk Supreme Open Cream
Kroger Gourmet Peach Raspberry Peach
The Schwan Food Company Gourmet Mrs. Smith's Cream Pie Peanut Butter
Kroger Gourmet Irish Cream Silk Cream
Cracker Barrel Gourmet No Sugar Added NSA Apple Pie Apple
Cyrus O'Leary's Pies Gourmet No Sugar Added Mostly Fruit Homestyle Marionberry Pie Fruit & Berry
Cyrus O'Leary's Pies Gourmet No Sugar Added Mostly Fruit Homestyle Peach Pie Peach
Bonert's Slice of Pie Hand Held Pie Raspberry Créme Cheese Pocket Fruit & Berry
Key West Key Lime Pie Co Hand Held Pie Key Lime Pie Bar Open
Sweetielicious Independent Mom Hundt's Apple Pie Apple
Sweetielicious Independent Tom's Cherry Raspberry Crisco® Classic Cherry
Michele's Pies Independent Pecan Nut
Michele's Pies Independent Thanksgiving Fresh Pumpkin Pie Pumpkin
Sweetielicious Independent Daddy's Raisin Mince Raisin
Michele's Pies Independent Country Apple Crumb Apple Crumb
Wayne's Family Restaurant Independent Strawberry Pie Berry
Lake Geneva Pie Company Independent Blueberry Crumb Blueberry
Michele's Pies Independent Trick or Treat Pie Candy/Cookie Cream
The Pie Folks Independent Slap Yo' Mama Pie Chocolate Cream
Michele's Pies Independent Coconut Cream Coconut Cream
Lake Geneva Pie Company Independent Key Lime Key Lime
Michele's Pies Independent Chocolate Peanut Butter Cream Open Cream
Lake Geneva Pie Company Independent Blackberry Peach Crumb Peach
Farmer's Kitchen Independent Chocolate Peanut Butter Explosion Peanut Butter
Pure Joy Bakery/The Lunch Pail Independent Pucker Up New Product
Michele's Pies Independent No Sugar Added Sugare Free Apple Pie Apple
Wayne's Family Restaurant Independent No Sugar Added Sugar Free Strawberry Fruit & Berry
Cyrus O'Leary's Pies Premium Fresh Apple Pie Apple
Jessie Lord Bakery LLC Premium Old Fhashioned Cherry 9" Crisco® Classic Cherry
Bakers Square Premium Lemon Meringue Citrus
Bonert's Slice of Pie Premium Custard Custard
Bob Evans Premium Strawberry Supreme Fruit & Berry
Bakers Square Premium Pecan Pie Nut
Bakers Square Premium Neapolitan Open
Cyrus O'Leary's Pies Premium Luscious Pumpkin Cream Pie Pumpkin
Bakers Square Premium Tutti Fruity Ambrosia Pie w/light & dark raisins Raisin
Cyrus O'Leary's Pies Premium Northwest Fresh Apple Cranberry Walnut Pie Apple Crumb
Cyrus O'Leary's Pies Premium Fresh Banana Cream Pie Banana Cream
Jessie Lord Bakery LLC Premium Old Fashioned Mixed Berry 9" Berry
Jessie Lord Bakery LLC Premium Old Fashioned Blueberry 9" Blueberry
Bakers Square Premium Candy Cane Silk Candy/Cookie Cream
Bonert's Slice of Pie Premium Chocolate Cream Chocolate Cream
Wick's Pies Premium Coconut Cream Coconut Cream
Bakers Square Premium Key Lime Key Lime
Bonert's Slice of Pie Premium Caramel Pecan Cream Open Cream
Bakers Square Premium Holiday Silk Open Cream
Rocky Mountain Pies Premium 9" VIP Peach Praline Lattice Peach
Kroger Premium Peanut Butter Passion Peanut Butter
Cyrus O'Leary's Pies Premium Where's the Party? Kahlua Cream Pie Silk Cream
Bonert's Slice of Pie Premium All American Pie New Product
Harlan Bakeries Premium No Sugar Added Apple Apple
Rocky Mountain Pies Premium No Sugar Added 9" NSA Cherry Pomegranante Crisco® Classic Cherry
Bonert's Slice of Pie Premium No Sugar Added NSA Lemon Meringue Citrus
Rocky Mountain Pies Premium No Sugar Added 9" NSA Rocky Mountain Berry Crumb Fruit & Berry
Bakers Square Premium No Sugar Added NSA Banana Cream Open
Bonert's Slice of Pie Premium No Sugar Added Pumpkin Pumpkin
Bonert's Slice of Pie Single Serve Slice Apple Apple
The Schwan Food Company Single Serve Slice Edwards Lemon Meringue Open
The Schwan Food Company Single Serve Slice Edwards Reese Singles Open Cream
Harlan Bakeries Super Gourmet 12" Lattice Apple Apple
Bakers Square Super Gourmet Cherry Supreme Crisco® Classic Cherry
Bakers Square Super Gourmet Cool and Creamy Dreamy Orange Citrus
Bakers Square Super Gourmet Blackberry Vanilla Bavarian Custard Custard
Bakers Square Super Gourmet Fresh Raspberry Supreme Fruit & Berry
Bakers Square Super Gourmet Butter Pecan French Silk Nut
Bakers Square Super Gourmet Yankee Doodle 4th of July Pie Open
Bakers Square Super Gourmet Triple Treate Pumpkin Supreme Pumpkin
Bakers Square Super Gourmet Banana Foster Banana Cream
Norske Nook Super Gourmet Strawberry Cream Cheese Berry
Bonert's Slice of Pie Super Gourmet Blueberry Blueberry
Norske Nook Super Gourmet Chocolate Peanut Butter Candy/Cookie Cream
Bakers Square Super Gourmet Triple Chocolate Treat Chocolate Cream
Key Lime Yummies Bakery Super Gourmet Key Lime Madness Key Lime
Bakers Square Super Gourmet Tin Roof Sundae Open Cream
J. Horner Super Gourmet Chocoloate Brownie Pile Up Open Cream
Bakers Square Super Gourmet Peach Supreme Peach
Bakers Square Super Gourmet PB and J Peanut Butter
J. Horner Super Gourmet Dark Chocolate Raspberry Truffle Silk Cream
Bakers Square Super Gourmet Foley's Mocha Cinnamon Supreme New Product