American Pie Council

And the 2019 Winners Are

The Winning Recipes are the property of the American Pie Council and cannot be used for commercial purposes without the written permission of the APC.

Amateur Best in Show

  Entrant Pie Flavor City, State
  Rhonda Hull Denali Caribou Crunch Pie My Favorite Vacation Little Rock, AR

Amateur Best in Comstock

  Entrant Pie Flavor City, State
  Ron Bronitsky Melba's A Peach Of A Pie Comstock/Wilderness Peach Los Ranchos, NM

Amateur Winners

Place Entrant Pie Flavor City, State
1 David Harper Apricot Apple Winkle Pie Apple Lone Rock, WI
2 Stephen Smith Heritage "Real Deal" Apple Pie Apple Chesapeake, VA
3 Catherine Colombo Lady Marlboroughs Apple Custard Pie Apple Chicago, IL
1 Rhonda Hull Im So Blueberry Pie Blueberry Little Rock, AR
2 David Harper Blueberry Lemon Torn Angel Food Pie Blueberry Lone Rock, WI
3 Naylet LaRochelle When Life Gives You Lemons... Blueberry Miami, FI
1 Rhonda Hull Chuckling Cherry Pie Cherry Little Rock, AR
2 David Harper Black Forest Cherry Trifle Pie Cherry Lone Rock, W
3 Joseph Cacciola Sweet Mississippi Moon Cherry Pie Cherry Windermere, FL
1 Beth Campbell Berry Delish Guittard Chocolate Pie Guittard Chocolate Cream Belleville, WI
2 David Harper German Chocolate Pie Guittard Chocolate Cream Lone Rock, WI
3 Patricia Lapiezo Chocolate Triple Layer Delight Guittard Chocolate Cream LaMesa, CA
1 Verlina Keener Calamondin Pie Citrus Apopka, FL
2 Patricia Lapiezo Greek Yogurt Lemon Pie Citrus LaMesa, CA
3 David Harper Strawberry Lime Chiffon Pie Citrus Lone Rock, WI
  Naylet LaRochelle Caramel Drizzled Apple Pie Comstock/Wilderness Apple Miami, FL
  Hunny Lee Delightfully Creamy White Chocolate Blueberry Comstock/Wilderness Blueberry Kokomo, IN
  Hunny Lee Chocolate Cherry Cream Cheese Brownie Pie Comstock/Wilderness Cherry Kokomo, IN
  Ron Bronitsky Melba's A Peach of a Pie Comstock/Wilderness Peach Los Ranchos, NM
  Joseph Cacciola Parisian Sunrise Strawberry Pie Comstock/Wilderness Strawberry Windermere, FL
1 Rhonda Hull Tropical Fantasy Pie Cream Little Rock, AR
2 Naylet LaRochelle Route 66 Banana Cream Diner Pie Cream Miami, FL
3 Melinda Johnson Chocolate Covered Strawberry Pie Cream Brooklyn, NY
1 Rhonda Hull Chocolate Chiffon with a Freckled Bottom Cream Cheese Little Rock, AR
2 Ron Bronitsky Pistachio Dream Cream Cheese Los Ranchos, NM
3 Jeanne Ely Pumpkin Cheesecake Pie Cream Cheese Mulberry, FL
1 David Harper Rhubarb Pie with a Strawberry on Top Fruit & Berry Lone Rock, WI
2 Jeanne Ely Pineapple Right Side Up Pie Fruit & Berry Mulberry, FL
3 Lori Panchisin Pear Chai Pie Fruit & Berry Holly Hill, FL
1 Rhonda Hull Denali Caribou Crunch Pie My Favorite Vacation Little Rock, AR
2 Ron Bronitsky Banana Split Meringue My Favorite Vacation Los Ranchos, NM
3 Naylet LaRochelle Polynesian Pineapple Survivor Pie My Favorite Vacation Miami, FL
1 Rebekah Noble Girl Power Apple Blackberry Walnut Pie Double Crust Pie Alexandria, IN
2 Ron Bronitsky Tropical Boysenberry Pie Double Crust Pie Los Ranchos, NM
3 Stephen Smith Traditional Apple Pie Covered with Texture of Fall Leaves Double Crust Pie Chesapeake, VA
1 Beth Campbell It's your Clucky Day Chicken Pot Pie 6" Chicken Pot Pie Belleville, WI
2 Rebekah Noble Power to the Chick Chicken Pot Pie 6" Chicken Pot Pie Alexandria, IN
3 Lois Spruytte Southern Spicy Chicken Pie 6" Chicken Pot Pie Richmond, MI
1 Melinda Johnson Hazelnut Cappuccino Pie Nut Brooklyn, NY
2 Patricia Lapiezo Maple Cream Walnut Pie Nut LaMesa, CA
3 Ron Bronitsky Bourbon Ginger Pecan Nut Los Ranchos, NM
1 Naylet LaRochelle Teeny Bikini Strawberry Coconut Pie Open Miami, FL
2 David Harper Raspberry Tiramisu Pie Open Lone Rock, WI
3 Jeanne Ely Banana Strawberry Sundae Pie Open Mulberry, FL
1 Melinda Johnson Peanut Butter S'Mores Pie Peanut Butter Brooklyn, NY
2 Naylet LaRochelle Thunder Mountain Peanut Butter Gold Pie Peanut Butter Miami, FL
3 Janet Ropp Let Me Call You Sweet Hot Peanut Butter Edgewater, FL
1 Rhonda Hull Streusel Topped Pumpkin Pie Pumpkin Little Rock, AR
2 Patricia Lapiezo Maple Kissed Pumpkin Pie Pumpkin LaMesa, CA
3 Janet Ropp Vera Mae's Merry Holidays Pumpkin Edgewater, FL
1 Rhonda Hull Dobla's Summer Sunset Pie Dobla Summer Orange Creamsicle Little Rock, AR
2 Hunny Lee Refreshing Mandarin Orange Pineapple Creamsicle Dobla Summer Orange Creamsicle Kokomo, IN
3 Jeanne Ely Life is but a Dream Dobla Summer Orange Creamsicle Mulberry, FL

Professional Best in Show

  Entrant Pie Flavor
  David Earheart Iceland's Cafe Loki Inspired Rye Bread Cream Best In Show

Professional Winners

Place Entrant Pie Flavor
1 Andrea Spring Crazy Quilt Apple Pie Apple
2 Katheryn Hanson How Deep is Your Love Apple Pie Apple
1 Lisa Sparks Razzle Up Your Blue Ball Pie Blueberry
2 Katheryn Hanson I Guess That's Why They Call It The Blues Blueberry Pie Blueberry
1 Paul Arguin Peakaboo Cherry Pie Cherry
2 Andy Hilton Cherry Pie Crumble Pi Cherry
1 Grace Huertas Guittard Chocolate 150th Anniversary Pie Chocolate Cream
2 Michele Stuart Fireside Chocolate Chocolate Smores Pie Chocolate Cream
1 Lisa Sparks Take Stock in Your Strawberry Pie Comstock
2 Susan Boyle Infused Blackberry Key Lime Comstock
1 Michele Stuart Double the Good Stuff Cookies and Cream Cream
2 Amy Freeze Sunsational Islandtime Coconut Cream Pie Cream
1 Andrea Spring Raspberry Revelation Fruit & Berry
2 Dionna Hurt Raspberry What? Fruit & Berry
1 Paul Arguin Pineapple Upside Down Pie Double Crust Pie
2 Susan Boyle Double Crusted Apple with a Cinnamon Twirt Double Crust Pie
1 David Eaheart Iceland's Cafe Loki Inspired Rye Bread Cream My Favorite Vacation
2 Katheryn Hanson Don't Forget Rocky Mountain Pie My Favorite Vacation
1 Lisa Sparks OH Honey Butter Up Your Cashew Pie Nut
2 Katheryn Hanson I'm Still Standing Mixed Up Nut Pie Nut
1 Amy Freeze Double Chocolate Macchiato Pie Open
2 Michele Stuart Sweet Strawberry of Mine Shortcake Open
1 Andy Hilton De Leche Peanut Butter Pie Peanut Butter
2 Christopher Taylor Peanut Butter Bliss Pie Peanut Butter
1 Sandra Speakman Sweet Dreams of Autumn Pumpkin Pie Pumpkin
2 Katheryn Hanson You Win Again Pumpkin Pie Pumpkin
1 Michele Stuart Creamy Traditional Chicken Vegetable 6" Chicken Pot Pie
2 Andy Hilton Chicken & Lobster & Wild Rice Pot Pie 6" Chicken Pot Pie
1 Christopher Taylor Tropical Orange Cream Pie Dobla Summer Orange Creamsicle
2 Andrea Spring To The Moon Pie Dobla Summer Orange Creamsicle

Commercial Winners

Category Flavor Entrant Pie
Family No Sugar Added Apple Harlan Bakeries 8" NSA Honey Crisp Apple
Family No Sugar Added Blueberry Harlan Bakeries 8" NSA Wild Blueberry
Family No Sugar Added Cherry Harlan Bakeries 8" NSA Cherry
Family No Sugar Added Citrus Harlan Bakeries 8" Sugar Free Lemon Meringue
Family No Sugar Added Fruit & Berry Harlan Bakeries 8" NSA Mixed Fruit
Family No Sugar Added Nut Southeastern Grocers NSA Pecan
Family No Sugar Added Open Harlan Bakeries 8" NSA Classic Berry
Family No Sugar Added Peach Harlan Bakeries 8" NSA Peach
Family No Sugar Added Pumpkin Jessie Lord Bakery 8" NSA Pumpkin SS
Family No Sugar Added Sweet Potato Walmart Inc. Patti LaBelle Sweet Potato Pie
Family Traditional Apple Rocky Mountain Pies Apple Lattice
Family Apple Southeastern Grocers SEG Apple Caramel Drizzle Pie
Family Apple Crumb Rocky Mountain Pies Caramel Apple Crumb
Family Banana Cream Rocky Mountain Pies Banana Crème
Family Berry Harlan Bakeries 8" Triple Berry
Family Blueberry Harlan Bakeries 8" HB Blueberry
Family Traditional Cherry Southeastern Grocers SEG Fresh Cherry Pie
Family Cherry Table Talk Pies Cherry Almond Crunch
Family Chocolate Cream Rocky Mountain Pies Sea Salt Caramel Chocolate
Family Citrus Rocky Mountain Pies Raspberry Lemonade
Family Baked Dairy Jessie Lord Bakery 8" Coconut Custard
Family Fruit & Berry Harlan Bakeries 8" Classic Berry
Family Galette Rocky Mountain Pies Peach Raspberry Galette
Family Guittard Chocolate Harlan Bakeries 8" Chocolate Maple Sugar Crème
Family New Product Southeastern Grocers SEG Apple Walnut Crunch Pie
Family Nut Table Talk Pies Pecan
Family Open Southeastern Grocers SEG French Apple Pie
Family Peach Harlan Bakeries 8" Spiced Peach
Family Pie Shell Wick's Pies 9" Shell
Family Pumpkin Weston Foods Blue Ribbon Pumpkin Pie
Family Shelf Stable Pumpkin Southeastern Grocers SEG Pumpkin Pie
Family Strawberry Weston Foods Sweet Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
Family Sweet Potato Walmart Inc. Patti LaBelle Sweet Potato Pie
Family Tropical Fruit Southeastern Grocers SEG Fresh Guava Cream Cheese Pie
Premium No Sugar Added Apple Something Sweet 9" Apple
Premium No Sugar Added Cherry Harlan Bakeries 10" NSA Cherry
Premium No Sugar Added Fruit & Berry Weston Foods Hold the Sugar Pineapple Pie
Premium Apple Harlan Bakeries 9" Country Apple
Premium Apple Crumb Weston Foods Apple Crumb Pie
Premium Banana Cream Jessie Lord Bakery 8" Banana Cream
Premium Berry Harlan Bakeries 9" Bursting with Berries
Premium Blueberry Table Talk Pies Natural Juice Blueberry
Premium Cherry Weston Foods I Only Have (Cherry) Pies for You
Premium Chocolate Cream Wick's Pies Baked GermanChocolate Cream
Premium Citrus Jessie Lord Bakery 8" Lemon Meringue Pie
Premium Coconut Cream Wick's Pies Coconut Cream Pie
Premium Fruit & Berry Weston Foods Cherry Lattice Pie
Premium Fruit, Berry & Cheese Kneader’s Restaurant Raspberry Cream Cheese Pie
Premium Galette Rocky Mountain Pies Apple Caramel Pecan
Premium Guittard Chocolate Weston Foods Guittard Chocolate Cherry Pie
Premium Key Lime Publix Super Markets Original Key Lime
Premium New Product Harlan Bakeries 9" Cheesecake Pecan Brittle
Premium Nut Harlan Bakeries 9" Buttery Pecan
Premium Open Cream Harlan Bakeries 9" Pumpkin Cream Cheese
Premium Open Southeastern Grocers SEG French Apple Walnut Pie
Premium Peach Harlan Bakeries 9" Peachy Keen
Premium Peanut Butter Wick's Pies Baked Peanut Butter
Premium Pumpkin Southeastern Grocers SEG Whipped Topped Pumpkin Pie 10"
Premium Shelf Stable Pumpkin Southeastern Grocers SEG Whipped Topped Pumpkin Pie 10"
Premium Silk Cream Rocky Mountain Pies S'mores French Silk
Premium Strawberry Weston Foods Strawbery Rhubarb Pie
Premium Sweet Potato Walmart, Inc. Patti LaBelle Family Size Sweet Potato Pie
Premium Tropical Fruit Publix Super Markets Mango Key Lime
Gourmet   Apple Jessie Lord Bakery 9" Caramel Apple Walnut Pie
Gourmet   Apple Crumb Weston Foods Caramel Apple Crumble Pie
Gourmet   Berry Something Sweet 10" Triple Berry Crumb Pie
Gourmet   Blueberry Weston Foods Wild Blueberry Pie
Gourmet   Cherry Jessie Lord Bakery 11" Cherry Crumb
Gourmet   Baked Dairy Jessie Lord Bakery 9" Pumpkin Cheesecake Streusel
Gourmet   Fruit & Berry Weston Foods Gourmet Apple Lattice Pie
Gourmet   Fruit, Berry & Cheese Something Sweet 10" Pumpkin Cream Cheese Swirl Pie
Gourmet   New Product Southeastern Grocers SEG French Apple Walnut Lattice Pie
Gourmet   Open Southeastern Grocers SEG French Apple Lattice Pie
Gourmet   Peach Weston Foods Peaches and Cream Pie
Gourmet   Pumpkin Weston Foods Gourmet Pumpkin Pie
Gourmet   Shelf Stable Pumpkin Jessie Lord Bakery 11" Pumpkin SS
Gourmet   Silk Cream Jessie Lord Bakery 9" French Silk
Gourmet   Strawberry Weston Foods Tangy Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
Super Gourmet   Apple Walmart, Inc. Member's Mark Wavy Apple Lattice Pie
Super Gourmet   Cherry Weston Foods Gourmet Cherry Lattice Pie
Super Gourmet   Fruit & Berry Weston Foods Best of Both Apple Cherry Lattice Pie
Super Gourmet   Guittard Chocolate Rocky Mountain Pies Sea Salt Caramel Chocolate Silk
Super Gourmet   Key Lime Mike's Pies Killer Key Lime Pie
Super Gourmet   New Product Weston Foods Tart Cherry Lattice Pie
Super Gourmet   Peanut Butter Mike's Pies Reese's Peanut Butter Pie
Super Gourmet   Pumpkin Weston Foods Fall Favorite Pumpkin Pie
Super Gourmet   Shelf Stable Pumpkin Walmart, Inc. Member's Mark Pumpkin Pie
Super Gourmet   Strawberry Weston Foods Strawberry Rhubarb Lattice Pie
Super Gourmet   Tropical Fruit Rocky Mountain Pies Pineapple Upside Down
Independent   Apple The Rose Plantation Double Crust Apple Pie
Independent   Banana Cream Sunset Grill Banana Crème
Independent   Blueberry Norske Nook Blueberry Lemonade
Independent   Chocolate Cream Lisa's Pie Shop German Chocolate Pie
Independent   Citrus A Fish Called Avalon Key Lime Pie
Independent   Baked Dairy Michele's Pies Lemon Chess Pie
Independent   Fruit & Berry Sunset Grill Blackberry Crème
Independent   Single Fruit & Berry The Rose Plantation Double Crust Tart Cherry Pie
Independent   Guittard Chocolate Michele's Pies Chocolate Walnut
Independent   No Sugar Added Sunset Grill Apple Pie
Independent   Nut The Rose Plantation Texas Pecan Pie
Independent   Open Cream Lisa's Pie Shop Put The Rise on Your Raspberry Pie
Independent   Open Michele's Pies Oreo
Independent   Peanut Butter Wayne's Family Restaurant Peanut Butter 
Independent   Pot Pie World of Pies LLC Spinach and Feta
Independent   Pumpkin Michele's Pies Pumpkin Crumb
Independent   Strawberry Michele's Pies Strawberry Glace
Hand Held Pie Apple Table Talk Pies Apple
Hand Held Pie Citrus Table Talk Pies Mango Pineapple
Hand Held Pie Coconut Cream Table Talk Pies Chocolate Coconut
Hand Held Pie Fruit & Berry Table Talk Pies Strawberry
Hand Held Pie Nut Table Talk Pies Chocolate Pecan
6" No Sugar Added Single Pie Apple Publix Super Markets No Sugar Added Apple 6"
6" No Sugar Added Single Pie Blueberry Publix Super Markets No Sugar Added Blueberry 6"
6" Single Pie Apple Rocky Mountain Pies Apple Caramel Crumb
6" Single Pie Blueberry Meijer Double Crust Blueberry Pie
6" Single Pie Cherry Publix Super Markets Small Cherry
6" Single Pie Citrus Publix Super Markets Mini Mango Key Lime
6" Single Pie Fruit & Berry Publix Super Markets Small Guava
6" Single Pie New Product Pot Pie Southeastern Grocers Premium Pizza Pot Pie
6" Single Pie New Product Sweet Publix Super Markets Small Pina Colada
6" Single Pie Open Cream Publix Super Markets Mini Toasted Coconut Cream
6" Single Pie Open Publix Super Markets Mini Key Lime
6" Single Pie Peach Publix Super Markets Small Peach
6" Single Pie Pot Pie Southeastern Grocers Traditional Premium Chicken Pot Pie
6" Single Pie Pumpkin Meijer Pumpkin Pie