American Pie Council

And the 2018 Winners are....

The Winning Recipes are the property of the American Pie Council and cannot be used for commercial purposes without the written permission of the APC.

Amateur Best in Show

  Entrant Pie Flavor City, State
  Jennifer Nystrom Chocolate Caramel Turtle Sundae Pie Guittard Chocolate Cream Clarksville, OH

Amateur Best in Comstock

  Entrant Pie Flavor City, State
  Rebekah Noble Boss Lady Blueberry-Lemon Pie Comstock/Wilderness Blueberry Alexandria, IN

Amateur Winners

Place Entrant Pie Flavor City, State
1 Rhonda Hull Dutch Apple with Cinnamon Swirl Crust Apple Little Rock, AR
2 Rebekah Noble Ramblin' Red Raspberry Apple Pie Apple Alexandria, IN
3 David Harper Apple Peanut Butter Pie Apple Lone Rick, WI
1 David Harper Blueberry Pineapple Pie Blueberry Lone Rock,
2 Jone Schumacher Very Berry Blueberry Pie Blueberry Chapin, IL
3 Joseph Cacciola Zest of Lemon Blueberry Cheesecake Pie Blueberry Windermere, FL
1 David Harper Cherry Winkle Pie Cherry

Lone Rock, WI

2 Beth Campbell Not My Grandma's Cherry Pie Cherry Belleville, WI
3 Carolyn Blakemore Sweetheart Cherry Pie Cherry Fairmont, WV
1 Jennifer Nystrom Chocolate Caramel Turtle Sundae Pie Guittard Chocolate Cream Clarksville, OH
2 Belinda Myers Chocolate Myrtle Turtle Pie Guittard Chocolate Cream Osceola, IA
3 Melinda Johnson Chocolate Hazelnut Truffle Pie Guittard Chocolate Cream Brooklyn, NY
1 Jeanne Ely Key Lime Cheesecake Pie Citrus Mulberry, FL
2 Jone Schumacher Creamy Key Lime Pie Citrus Chapin, IL
3 Steve Delph Lemony Limoncello Custard Pie Citrus Lakeland, FL
1 Joseph Cacciola Fall in Vermont Maple Praline Pie Comstock/Wilderness Apple Windermere, FL
1 Rebekah Noble Boss Lady Blueberry-Lemon Pie Comstock/Wilderness Blueberry Alexandria, IN
1 Hunny Lee Chocolate Lover Covered Cherry Comstock/Wilderness Cherry Kokomo, IN
1 Joseph Cacciola Sunday Brunch Raspberry Bellini Pie Comstock/Wilderness Peach Windermere, FL
1 Carolyn Blakemore Strawberry Rhubarb Pie Comstock/Wilderness Strawberry Fairmont, WV
1 Sandy Pearce Salted Baked Caramel Dream Cream Sheboygan Falls, WI
2 Jeanne Ely Tropicolada Pie Cream Mulberry, FL
3 Joseph Cacciola Italian Romance Tiramisu Pie Cream Windermere, FL
1 Rhonda Hull Ebony & Ivory Tim Tam Pie Cream Cheese Little Rock, AR
2 Jennifer Nystrom After Dinner Mint Pie Cream Cheese Clarksville, OH
3 Helen Fields Exotic Lands Honey and Spice Pie Cream Cheese Paradise, TX
1 Rhonda Hull Mixed Berry Supreme Pie Fruit & Berry Little Rock, AR
2 Sandy Pearce Cranberry Fluff Delight Fruit & Berry Sheboygan Falls, WI
3 Jone Schumacher Peachy Peach Pie Fruit & Berry Chapin, IL
1 Rhonda Hull Pretty Woman's Pretty Neopolitan Pie Hollywood Little Rock, AR
2 Jennifer Nystrom Wilson's Suprirse Castaway Coconut Cream Pie Hollywood Clarksville, OH
3 Helen Fields The Pie Abides Hollywood Paradise, TX
1 Jennifer Nystrom Sweet Potato Pecan Crunch Pie Hand Crafted Artisan Clarksville, OH
2 Patricia Lapiezo Cinnamon Roll Banana Creamy Hand Crafted Artisan LaMesa, CA
3 Christina Shum Samoa Pie Hand Crafted Artisan Orlando, FL
1 Rebekah Noble Perky Purdy Chicken Pot Pie 6" Chicken Pot Pie Alexandria, IN
2 Hunny Lee Chickity Chicks Chicen Pot Pie 6" Chicken Pot Pie Kokomo, IN
3 Lois Spruytte Darn Clucking Good Pie 6" Chicken Pot Pie Richmond, MI
1 Janet Ropp Aloha Friday Nut Edgewater, FL
2 Rhonda Hull Busy Bees Honey Caramel Solid Nut Pie Nut Little Rock, AR
3 Helen Fields Ain't Just Whistlin' Dixie Peanut Pie Extreme Nut Paradise, TX
1 Patricia Lapiezo Muddy Buddy Open LaMesa, CA
2 Lori Panchisin Gonna Make a Mint Off This Pie Open Holly Hill, FL
3 David Harper Black Currant Tiramisu Open Lone Rock, WI
1 Rhonda Hull Simply Delightful Peanut Butter Pie Peanut Butter Little Rock, AR
2 Janet Ropp Ruthie in the Sky Peanut Butter Edgewater, FL
3 Jeanne Ely Honey Be Mine Peanut Butter Pie Peanut Butter Mulberry, FL
1 Jeanne Ely Pumpkin with Salted Caramel Streusel Pumpkin Mulberry, FL
2 Jone Schumacher Cold and Creamy Pumpkin Pie Pumpkin Chapin, IL
3 David Harper Orange Kissed Apple Butter Pumpkin Pie Pumpkin Lone Rock, WI

Professional Best in Show

  Entrant Pie Flavor City, State
  Katheryn Hanson I Love a Great Love Pie Best In Show Orlando, FL

Professional Winners

Place Entrant Pie Flavor City, State
1 Susan Boyle Pink Lady and Friends Apple DeBary, FL
2 Paul Arguin Apple Blossom Pie Apple Atlanta, FL
1 Lisa Sparks Boo Blue Black and Blueberry Pie Blueberry Atlanta, IN
2 Paul Arguin Lemon Blueberry Pie Blueberry Atlanta, GA
1 Andy Hilton My Sweet Chocolate Cherry Pie Cherry Davenport, FL
2 Caroline Imig Cherry Almond Crunch Cherry Oconto, WI
1 Kim Montello The Step Mother's Bitter Sweet Pie Chocolate Cream Orlando, FL
2 Christopher Taylor Chocolate Hazelnut Crunch Pie Chocolate Cream Atlanta, GA
1 Kim Montello 100% Fresh Squeezed True Key Lime Pie Citrus Hollywood, FL
2 Andy Hilton Honey Lemon Bumble Bee Pie Citrus Davenport, FL
1 Lisa Sparks Risen Raspberry Pie Comstock Atlanta, IN
2 Paul Arguin Chocolate Covered Cherry Jackpot Pie Comstock Atlanta, GA
1 Kim Montello Peanut Butter Hazelnut Pie Cream Hollywood, FL
2 Christopher Taylor Black Bottom Bananas Foster Pie Cream Atlanta, GA
1 Paul Arguin Tropical Punch Pineapple Pie Fruit & Berry Atlanta, GA
2 Susan Boyle Cranberry Apple Almond Crunch Fruit & Berry DeBary, FL
1 Keelin Martin Browned Butteh Bread Pudding Pie Hand Crafted Artisan Cutler Bay, FL
2 Lisa Sparks Passionate About My Pie Hand Crafted Artisan Atlanta, IN
1 Katheryn Hanson The Evil Queens Chocolate Pie Hollywood Movies Orlando, FL
2 Lisa Sparks My Statement Pie Hollywood Movies Atlanta, IN
1 Andrea Spring Cashew Butter Turtle Pie Nut Bradenton, FL
2 Lisa Sparks Fudge Bottom Cashew Crunch Pie Nut Atlanta, IN
1 Lisa Sparks Strawberry Explosion Pie Open Atlanta, IN
2 Katheryn Hanson Harley Quinn's Poppins Pie Open Orlando, FL
1 Sandra Speakman America's Favorite Peanut Butter Brownie Pie Peanut Butter Lincoln University
2 Lisa Sparks Sit-n-On a Ritz Pie Peanut Butter Atlanta, IN
1 Katheryn Hanson At the Stroke of Mid-Night Pumpkin Pie Pumpkin Orlando, FL
2 Andy Hilton Boo Pumpkin Pecan Maple Pie Pumpkin Davenport, FL
1 Andrea Spring Moraccan Chicken Pot Pie 6" Chicken Pot Pie Bradenport, FL
2 David Eaheart Bacon & Chicken Sausage Pot Pie 6" Chicken Pot Pie Kansas City, MO
1 Katheryn Hanson I Love a Great Love Pie Royal Wedding Orlando, FL
2 Christopher Taylor Crowning Glory Royal Wedding Pie Royal Wedding Atlanta, GA

Commercial Winners

Category Flavor Entrant Pie
Gourmet   Apple Crumb Albertson's 11" GS Dutch Apple Pie
Super Gourmet   Berry Albertson's 11" Very Berry Pie
Premium No Sugar Added Apple Bakers Square NSA Apple
Premium No Sugar Added Peach Bakers Square NSA Peach
Premium Blueberry Bakers Square Fruitabulous Blueberry Pie
Premium Fruit & Berry Bakers Square Peach Blueberry Almond Streusel Pie
Premium New Product Bakers Square Spumoni Pie
Premium Nut Bakers Square Pecan Pie
Premium Open Cream Bakers Square Nutella Pie
Premium Open Bakers Square Neapolitan Pie
Premium Peach Bakers Square Fruitabulous Peach Pie
Premium Peanut Butter Bakers Square Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
Premium Tropical Fruit Bakers Square Pina Colada Pie
Gourmet   Cherry Bakers Square Cherry Supreme Pie
Gourmet   Fruit & Berry Bakers Square Apple Blueberry Cherry Red White and Blue Pie
Gourmet   New Product Bakers Square Ghiridelli Chocolate Cream Pie
Gourmet   Nut Bakers Square Almond Cookie Butter Pie
Gourmet   Pumpkin Bakers Square Pumpkin Cream Pie
Gourmet   Tropical Fruit Bakers Square Banana Coconut Pie
Super Gourmet   Blueberry Bakers Square Blueberry Lemon Supreme Elite Pie
Super Gourmet   Cherry Bakers Square White Chocolate Cherry Dream Pie
Super Gourmet   Citrus Bakers Square Creamy Orange Float Pie
Super Gourmet   Fruit & Berry Bakers Square Fresh Red Raspberry Supreme Pie
Super Gourmet   Fruit, Berry & Cheese Bakers Square Yankee Doodle Dandy 4th of July Pie
Super Gourmet   Open Bakers Square Salty Hog Chocolate Pie
Super Gourmet   Peach Bakers Square Peach Pecan Coconut Supreme Pie
Super Gourmet   Pumpkin Bakers Square Pumpkin Supreme Pie
Independent   Chocolate Cream Hard Core Pies Deep-End Dark Chocolate
Independent   Baked Dairy Hard Core Pies Peach Melba Cream Pie
Independent   Pumpkin Hard Core Pies The Great Pumpkin
Family No Sugar Added Cherry Harlan Bakeries 8" NSA Cherry Pie
Family No Sugar Added Citrus Harlan Bakeries 8" SF Lemon Meringue Pie
Family No Sugar Added Fruit & Berry Harlan Bakeries 8" NSA Berry Blueberry Pie
Family No Sugar Added Open Harlan Bakeries 8" NSA Classic Berry Pie
Family Berry Harlan Bakeries 8" HB Triple Berry Pie
Family Blueberry Harlan Bakeries 8" Blueberry Pie
Family Citrus Harlan Bakeries 8" HB Lemon Meringue Pie
Family Fruit & Berry Harlan Bakeries 8" Classic Berry Pie
Family Key Lime Harlan Bakeries 8" Summertime Key Lime Pie
Family Open Harlan Bakeries 8" Maple Cranberry Honey Crisp Apple Pie
Family Peach Harlan Bakeries 8" Spiced Peach Pie
Premium No Sugar Added Cherry Harlan Bakeries 10" NSA Cherry Pie
Premium No Sugar Added Fruit & Berry Harlan Bakeries 10" NSA Mixed Fruit Pie
Premium Apple Crumb Harlan Bakeries 9" Apple Caramel Crunch
Premium Berry Harlan Bakeries 9" Bursting with Berries Pie
Premium Cherry Harlan Bakeries 9" Classic Cherry Pie
Premium Coconut Cream Harlan Bakeries 9" Coconut Cream Pie
Family No Sugar Added Blueberry Legendary Baking NSA Blueberry
Family Banana Cream Legendary Baking Banana Cream Pie
Family Traditional Cherry Legendary Baking Cherry Pie
Family Coconut Cream Legendary Baking Coconut Cream Pie
Family Nut Legendary Baking Caramel Pecan Pie
Family Open Cream Legendary Baking Cookies and Cream Pie
Family Silk Cream Legendary Baking French Silk Pie
Family Sweet Potato Legendary Baking Sweet Potato Pie
Premium Galette Legendary Baking Black Cherry Raspberry Galette
Premium Shelf Stable Pumpkin Legendary Baking Pumpkin Pie
Premium Sweet Potato Legendary Baking Sweet Potato Pie
Gourmet No Sugar Added Apple Legendary Baking NSA Apple
Gourmet   Berry Legendary Baking Chocolate Raspberry Pie
Gourmet   Blueberry Legendary Baking White Chocolate Blueberry Pie
Gourmet   Galette Legendary Baking Cherry Supreme Pie
Super Gourmet   Apple Crumb Legendary Baking Caramel Apple Oat Streusel Pie
Super Gourmet   Galette Legendary Baking Fresh Berry Supreme Galette
Super Gourmet   Tropical Fruit Legendary Baking Peach Pecan Coconut Supreme Pie
Single Serve Slice Open Legendary Baking Oreo Cookie Pie Slice
6" Single Pie Cherry Legendary Baking Black Cherry Pie
6" Single Pie Nut Legendary Baking Bourbon Pecan
6" Single Pie Open Legendary Baking Peach Lattice Pie
Independent   Apple Lisa's Pie Shop Caramel Walnutty Apple Pie
Independent   Blueberry Lisa's Pie Shop My Balls are Blue
Independent   Fruit & Berry Lisa's Pie Shop Mixed Confusion
Independent   Single Fruit & Berry Lisa's Pie Shop Peachy Pinwheel Pie
Independent   Nut Lisa's Pie Shop My Nuts are Mixed Up
Independent   Banana Cream Norske Nook Toffee Banana
Family No Sugar Added Pumpkin Publix SuperMarkets NSA Pumpkin
Family Traditional Apple Publix SuperMarkets Apple Pie
Family Baked Dairy Publix SuperMarkets Coconut Custard
Premium Key Lime Publix SuperMarkets Original Key Lime Pie
6" Single Pie Citrus Publix SuperMarkets Mini Mango Key Lime
6" Single Pie Fruit & Berry Publix SuperMarkets Small Blueberry
6" Single Pie Open Cream Publix SuperMarkets Mini Toasted Coconut Cream
Family No Sugar Added Peach Rocky Mountain Pies Peach NSA
Family Apple Crumb Rocky Mountain Pies Caramel Apple Crumb
Family Chocolate Cream Rocky Mountain Pies Sea Salt Caramel Chocolate
Family Galette Rocky Mountain Pies Peach Raspberry Galette
Family Shelf Stable Pumpkin Rocky Mountain Pies Shelf Stable Pumpkin
Premium Chocolate Cream Rocky Mountain Pies Whole Foods Triple Chocolate
Premium Citrus Rocky Mountain Pies Lemon Ice
Premium Silk Cream Rocky Mountain Pies Sea Salt Caramel French Silk
Super Gourmet   New Product Rocky Mountain Pies Sea Salt Caramel Apple Pie
Gourmet   Apple Sam's Club Sam's 10" Apple Pie
Gourmet   Citrus Sam's Club Sam's 10" Lemon Supreme Pie
Gourmet   Baked Dairy Sam's Club Sam's 10" Pumpkin Spice Latte Pie
Gourmet   Open Sam's Club Sam's 10" Irish Cream Pie
Super Gourmet   Nut Sam's Club Sam's 12" Pecan Pie
Super Gourmet   Silk Cream Sam's Club Sam's 12" French Silk Pie
6" Single Pie Apple Sam's Club Apple Lattice Pie
Family No Sugar Added Nut Southeastern Grocers NSA Pecan
Family Apple Southeastern Grocers 8" Fresh Apple Pie
Family Cherry Southeastern Grocers 8" Fresh Baked Cherry Pie
Family New Product Southeastern Grocers Chicken Cordon Bleu Pot Pie
Family Pot Pie Southeastern Grocers Chicken Pot Pie
Family Tropical Fruit Southeastern Grocers 8" Guava Cream Pie
Premium Apple Southeastern Grocers 9" Apple Caramel Drizzle Pie
Premium Pumpkin Southeastern Grocers 10" Pumpkin Cream Cheese Icing
Independent   Citrus Sunset Grill Key Lime
Independent   No Sugar Added Sunset Grill Mixed Berry
Independent   Peanut Butter Sunset Grill Peanut Butter Crème
Hand Held Pie Apple Table Talk 4" Caramel Apple
Hand Held Pie Fruit & Berry Table Talk 4" Bumbleberry Pie
Hand Held Pie Nut Table Talk 4" Pecan
Hand Held Pie Pumpkin Table Talk 4" Pumpkin
Hand Held Pie Sweet Potato Table Talk 4" Sweet Potato
Independent   Open Cream Wayne's Family Restaurants Cranberry Yummy Pie
Independent   Open Wayne's Family Restaurants Butterscotch Pie
Independent   Strawberry Wayne's Family Restaurants Strawberry Surprise Pie
Family No Sugar Added Apple Weston Foods NSA Apple 
Family Pumpkin Weston Foods Pumpkin
Family Strawberry Weston Foods Strawberry Rhubarb
Premium Strawberry Weston Foods Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
Family Pie Shell Wick's Pies 9" Shell
Premium Pot Pie Wick's Pies 5" Pot Pie
Independent   Pot Pie World of Pies Steak, Bacon & Ale Pie